Sustainable Gift Wrapping: The Scrunch Test, Furoshiki, and What to Do With All Those Boxes

The best wrapping is what you already have: a gift bag from last year, a box, a scarf, a tea towel, last Sunday's paper. Everything else is a step down. Here's how to tell what's recyclable, what to buy if you need it, and what to do with the boxes.
Do first: skip glitter, foil wrap, and plastic ribbon. Worth doing: wrap in fabric, reused paper, or recycled kraft, and recycle the cardboard.
The scrunch test
Most conventional wrapping paper can't be recycled. The shine, glitter, foil, and plastic laminates that make it pretty are what keep it out of the recycling stream. To check: scrunch a piece into a ball. If it springs back, it's coated and goes in the trash. If it stays scrunched, it's probably recyclable (but check your local rules, since some programs don't take it at all). Glitter and foil wrap: trash, every time.
Your options, best to worst
1. Reuse what you have
Gift bags, boxes, tissue, ribbon, last year's paper.

2. Fabric (furoshiki)
The Japanese technique of wrapping with a square of fabric, practiced for over a thousand years. Use a scarf, bandana, napkin, or tea towel, and the wrapping becomes part of the gift. No paper, no tape, no waste.

3. Recycled or kraft paper
Look for a high percentage of post-consumer waste (PCW). Decorate with twine, dried oranges, or greenery.

4. FSC-certified paper
Responsibly sourced, though still single-use.

5. Compostable, dissolvable, or seed paper
Plant-based paper that composts or dissolves in water; seed paper can be planted. Look for BPI certification and whether it's rated for home or industrial composting.

Skip: foil and metallic paper, holographic paper, glitter, and plastic curling ribbon. Use cotton twine, jute, raffia, or reused ribbon instead.
Shop
- Fabric wraps / furoshiki: Happy Wrap Furoshiki, Waste Free Celebrations furoshiki wraps
- Reusable fabric gift bags: K Benson Creates drawstring gift bags, Waste Free Celebrations Sew Your Own Gift Bags, BAGGU reusable bags
- Recycled kraft paper (high PCW): Happy Wrap Recycled Wrapping Paper
- Dissolvable wrapping paper: Waterleaf Paper Co. Dissolvable Wrapping Paper, or Grove Dissolvable Wrapping Paper
- Seed paper: Botanical PaperWorks seed paper
Tape, ribbon, bows, and tags
- Tape: plastic tape left on paper contaminates recycling. Use washi paper tape, skip tape with furoshiki, or take it off before recycling.
- Ribbon: cotton, jute, or reused ribbon. Save good ribbon every year.
- Bows: reuse them, or use biodegradable paper bows.
- Tags: cut them from last year's cards.
- Tissue paper: the fibers are too short to recycle well. Reuse it or compost it.
- Gift bags: the most reusable wrapping there is. Keep them and reuse them.
Shop
- Cotton ribbon: Waterleaf Paper Co. Cotton Ribbon
- Biodegradable bows: Waterleaf Paper Co. Biodegradable Bows
- Paper washi tape: The Washi Tape Shop 20-Piece Set
Holiday cards
- Digital cards have the smallest footprint; a printed card is still lovely if it gets kept.
- If you print: recycled paper, no glitter or foil (it makes the whole card trash), and plantable seed-paper cards are a nice touch.
- Cards you receive: cut them into gift tags for next year, then recycle anything without foil or glitter.
Shop: Botanical PaperWorks plantable holiday cards, Paper Culture (recycled paper; plants a tree with each order)
The cardboard mountain
Between Black Friday and Christmas, the boxes pile up. The good news: cardboard is one of the most recycled materials in the country (the paper industry's trade group puts the corrugated box recycling rate above 90%, though independent analysts estimate it's closer to two-thirds).
- Break it down. Flat boxes fit in the bin and are easier to process.
- Tape and shipping labels can stay on. They're removed in the recycling process.
- Pull out the plastic. Air pillows, bubble wrap, and plastic mailers can't go in with cardboard. Many shipping stores take back packing peanuts and air pillows to reuse; store drop-offs or services like Ridwell take plastic film.
- Styrofoam blocks and packing peanuts usually can't go curbside; some shipping stores take peanuts, and mail-back or drop-off programs take foam.
- Pizza boxes: tear off the greasy part and recycle the rest (check your local rules).
- Set up a station if you're expecting a lot of deliveries.
- Reuse first: good boxes are the cheapest toys for your kids, next year's gift boxes, and storage for decor.
Shop: Ridwell (curbside pickup for hard-to-recycle items); TerraCycle Zero Waste Box
After the holidays
Do the scrunch test again before anything goes in the bin. Save bags, bows, boxes, and ribbon in one bin for next year. Taking the tree down too? See what to do with it in January.
Subscribe now to continue reading.
(16% discount)
• Access to unlimited articles
• Sustainable product guides & recommendations
• Weekly newsletters
Already a member? Log in.










