Sustainability, made simple (and fun) for kids.
Coloring books and activity packs that help kids learn by doing.
Shop Now

How to Give Better (and Less Wasteful) Gifts This Holiday Season

Updated on
November 16, 2026
founder of finch
By Lizzie Horvitz
Finch Founder

The best gift is the one that gets used, kept, or remembered, and those tend to be the lowest-waste gifts too. Before you buy anything, run it down the Finch gift hierarchy.

The Finch gift hierarchy

The higher up, the lower the footprint (and usually, the more the gift gets remembered).

  1. An experience. Nothing to ship, wrap, store, or throw away.
  2. Something they'll use up. Good coffee, a candle, a hand cream you know they'll finish.
  3. Secondhand, vintage, or refurbished. The most sustainable new-to-them thing there is.
  4. Handmade or made locally.
  5. New, and made to last. Durable, repairable, from a brand that holds up to scrutiny, and something they'll use for years.

What drops off the list entirely: novelty gifts, gag gifts, "stuff for the sake of stuff," and anything with a battery that's only funny once.

Looking for picks by person? See our gift guides for kids, the host, the cook, and your partner.

‍

1. Gift an experience.

Experiences are the gift people remember, and they almost never end up in a landfill. Classes (cooking, pottery, a climbing gym), tickets (concerts, a game, the theater), memberships (museums, zoos, botanical gardens, national parks), a subscription they'll actually use, and "a day with me" coupons for kids, parents, and grandparents.

Make it feel like a gift on the day: wrap a small object that stands for it (a wooden spoon for a cooking class, a trail map for the national parks pass), or print a one-page itinerary.

‍

Our picks:

‍

2. Gift something they'll use up.

Gift cards, the honest version

Gift cards get called lazy. They're not: the least wasteful gift is the one that gets used, and a gift card for the place someone already goes beats a sweater they'll return. The problem is the ones that don't get used. Bankrate found 43% of U.S. adults are sitting on at least one unused gift card, about $27 billion nationwide, averaging $244 a person.

How to give one that gets used:

  • Pick the specific place they already go (their coffee shop, their bookstore), not a generic card.
  • Or pick a treat they wouldn't buy themselves. I got a scalp spa gift card from a family friend last year and didn't know I needed that in my life, but it was incredible, and I've now given the same experience to friends. 
  • Choose an e-gift card over plastic. Plastic gift cards are PVC and can't be recycled. If you want something physical to hand over, a printed e-gift card still beats plastic.
  • By federal law, most gift cards can't expire for at least five years from activation.

Holding unused cards yourself? Use them in January, combine them with a sale, resell them on a gift card exchange, or donate them (several charities accept gift cards).

Our picks: Rothy's Virtual Gift Card; e-gift cards from Patagonia, Raven + Lily, Saje, and 100% Pure.

‍

3. Gift secondhand, vintage, and refurbished

Secondhand gifts shouldn't feel cheap. They're the smart buy: vintage is a style, top brands run their own resale programs with like-new clothing and gear, and refurbished electronics come with warranties. Frame it as what it is: a better version of the thing, chosen carefully.

  • Clothing and gear: brand resale programs sell inspected, like-new items at a discount.
  • Designer and luxury: consignment platforms authenticate what they sell, offer a steeper discount than a brick-and-mortar consignment shop can, and prioritize quality for brand safety.
  • Electronics: buy refurbished, with a warranty, from the manufacturer or a certified refurbisher.
  • Home and decor: vintage glassware, cast iron, and wool blankets are often better made than new.
  • Books: used bookstores, or a first edition of a book that matters to them (worried about germs and bugs? Put them in the freezer for 24 hours).

Our picks:

‍

4. Gift handmade or made locally.

Often the gift people keep longest. It doesn't have to be crafty: the best homemade gifts are things you already make well.

  • From the kitchen: granola, spiced nuts, a cookie mix layered in a jar, flavored salt or sugar, or a loaf of bread. Package it in a jar or tin they can reuse. Skip homemade garlic- or herb-infused oils, which can grow botulism at room temperature. 
  • For the house: beeswax fire starters [link: what to put in the living room], a dried-orange garland, or a set of beeswax wraps you make yourself.
  • Something written down: a family recipe card, a letter, or a printed photo with the story behind it.
  • Something you know how to do: a knitted hat, a mended favorite sweater, a framed print of your own photo, or a lesson in the thing you're good at.
  • From the garden: seeds you saved, a cutting from a houseplant in a thrifted pot, or a bundle of dried herbs.

‍

Giving to a cause as a gift (and Giving Tuesday, Dec 1)

A donation in someone's name is the gift with no footprint at all. It's perfect for the person who has everything, grandparents who keep asking you not to buy them anything, and coworkers. Make it personal: pick a cause that matches them (their national park, their local animal shelter, the river they fish), and print a card that says what the donation does.

  • Food banks: give money, not cans. Food banks buy in bulk from manufacturers and farms at a fraction of retail. Feeding America says $1 can help provide about 10 meals. If you do a food drive, ask the food bank what it actually needs.
  • Coat and toy drives: new or excellent condition only.
  • Volunteer as a tradition: serve a meal, sort at a food bank, clean up a park on the solstice (Dec 21).
  • How to choose: Charity Navigator for transparency; for climate giving, look for groups with measurable outcomes. 

‍

Gift new, and made to last.

Electronics

  • Buy refurbished with a warranty for phones, laptops, tablets, headphones, and e-readers.
  • Recycle or trade in the device the new one replaces, before it disappears into a drawer.
  • Skip gadgets that will be in a drawer by February. An e-reader only beats paper books if you read 40–50 books on it.

Clothing and beauty

  • Vet the brand, not the "eco collection." Fast-fashion brands' sustainable collections don't fix the biggest issue, which is how much they make. (Our Quince investigation is a good example of how to check claims.) 
  • Natural fibers that last: wool, cashmere, organic cotton, linen.
  • Beauty gift sets come with a lot of packaging. A full-size product they already love beats a sampler they won't finish.

Home

  • Buy cast iron, carbon steel, or stainless pans instead of nonstick. Nonstick coatings wear out, but cast iron can outlast the cook. 
  • Opt for wool and linen for throws and bedding. They last longer, and they don’t shed microplastics in the wash.
  • Things that can be maintained: a good knife that can be sharpened, a wooden cutting board that can be oiled, a lamp that takes standard bulbs.

Our picks: Apple Certified Refurbished, Apple Trade In, Outerknown Woolaroo Jacket, Caraway Enameled Cast Iron Dutch Oven, Parachute Soft Spun Cotton Throw, John Boos Cherry Cutting Board.

‍

Gifting Etiquette

Asking for fewer (or better) gifts

The other half of a lower-waste holiday is what comes in. A few ways to ask without sounding ungrateful:

  • Make a list, and share it early. A specific wish list gets you things you'll use instead of guesses.
  • Ask for experiences and consumables by name: a class, a membership, your favorite coffee.
  • Suggest a one-gift rule or a Secret Santa for the adults in the family, so everyone buys one good thing instead of five small ones.
  • Say yes to secondhand, out loud. Most people won't assume used is welcome unless you tell them.
  • For kids: ask grandparents for one gift plus an experience together, or a contribution to a class or savings account.

‍

Shopping the sales: Black Friday (Nov 27), Small Business Saturday (Nov 28), Cyber Monday (Nov 30)

  • Shop from a list, not the deals. The most expensive and wasteful thing on Black Friday is the thing you didn't need.
  • Consolidate your orders. One box, not five; choose slower shipping when it's offered. Fuller trucks, fewer trips.
  • Buy local on Small Business Saturday, especially for gifts that are hard to find online.
  • Check whether the deal is a deal. Price trackers show whether the "sale" price is real.
  • Ship early. Rush shipping usually means air freight and half-empty trucks. USPS recommends mailing by Dec 17 (Ground Advantage and First-Class Mail), Dec 18 (Priority Mail), or Dec 19 (Priority Mail Express) for delivery by Dec 25. 
  • Avoid the return. Returns are where a lot of holiday waste hides. Shoppers send back up to $120 billion worth of products between Thanksgiving and the end of January, and the returns firm Optoro estimates billions of pounds of returned goods end up in landfills every year, because inspecting and reshelving them often costs more than they're worth. Buy the right size and the right thing the first time, and include a gift receipt so an unwanted gift gets exchanged, not trashed.

‍

After the holidays: unwanted gifts and old devices

  • Unwanted gifts: regift to someone who will love it (never back into the same circle), resell it, donate it, or exchange it within the return window. Your local Buy Nothing group on Facebook is great here.
  • Returns: in store when you can, and only if you have to.
  • The devices the new ones replaced: wipe your data, then recycle or trade them in (manufacturer trade-in programs, retailer electronics recycling). Recycle batteries separately; never put lithium batteries in the trash or curbside bin.
  • New Year's resolutions: try one small sustainability change a month, not a whole new life on January 1 (see our monthly resolution series).

Our picks: Best Buy in-store recycling, Apple Trade In, Back Market trade-in; TerraCycle Zero Waste Box for hard-to-recycle items.

‍

More from the Finch Holiday Guide

Gift guides [link: holiday gift guides] · Wrapping it [link: how to wrap it] · The holiday table [link: what to put on the table]

Subscribe now to continue reading.

$5/month
GET MONTHLY
$50/year
(16% discount)
GET annual
As a member you’ll get :
• Access to unlimited articles
• Sustainable product guides & recommendations
• Weekly newsletters

Already a member? Log in.